On Friday afternoon, the TDC and CVB called to order a meeting regarding additional funds added to the summer marketing budget. To recap, the dollars previously spent totaled 1 million dollars and went towards saturating primary targets areas Atlanta, Birmingham and Nashville with an advertising media mix of 40% cable advertising, 30% online, 24% outdoor and 6% magazine. This campaign, to date, has been successful. Dan Rowe, chairman of the TDC, acknowledged this success stating that the daily site traffic to the website has increased three-fold since the start of the campaign and the URL has moved up several thousand places in quantcast rankings.
With so much early success (we haven’t yet seen the complete outcome of results) the board decided to hit the markets harder, considering bolstering the marketing efforts with an additional $500,000. The board was presented three recommendations, one from the current advertising partner Y partnership, one from JB Inc. and a local broadcast recommendation. The recommendations broke down as follows:
Y Partnership Recommendation
- Extend Cable Buys
- Nine weeks versus six weeks
- $215,00
- Internet TV in AL, TN, KY and Stl, Indy and Cincy
- Hulu.com, CBS.com, NBC.com
- 7.2 million impressions, 10x frequency
- $186,815
- Local Broadcast TV
- Knoxville, Lexington, Waco/Bryan
- 12 Weeks, 90% reach, 10x frequency
- $73,185
Total Investment = $475,000
JB Inc Recommendation
- Showcase TV Ad on NBC.com, HULU.com, Oxygen.com
- Thirteen Weeks
- 9.5 million impressions
- Geo-targeted buys focusing East US & TC
- $230,000
- Extend Run of Network Video Banner (TV Spot)
- Sites TBD – (e.g. CBS.com, Facebook)
- 2.6 million impressions
- $30,000
Total Investment = $230,000
Local Broadcast TV recommendation
- Gray Television – 10 Stations: AL, FL, TN, KY, TX, MS
- Seventeen Weeks
- 13.7 million impressions
- Reach=91.3%, 10.9 frequency
- Will run on local news, morning shows, and prime-time TV
- Billfish programming with on air mention during tournament and other times during campaign
- $165,000 media flight, $25,000 billfish
- Hoak Television – 3 station in LA – Monroe and Alexandria
- Twelve Weeks
- Reach = 91.5% 10.2 Frequency
- $30,000
Total Investment = $220,000
These were only recommendations as to how the money should be spent and it became instantly apparent that Y-partnership would be the odd-man out. Even Mr. Buddy Wilkes didn’t care for Y’s recommendation saying they came up with, “quick ideas with very little thought” and that they, “didn’t come up with anything creative.” He didn’t have to mention the massive price tag on a less than stellar service that JB Inc and LBTV could produce at half the cost and better results. The recommendation from Y encountered such bad reviews that the overall partnership with them may be in jeopardy. To that point, Mr. Yonnie Patronis added, “This is an opportunity to test the waters with someone else.”
The board decided to go with a combination of JB Inc.’s recommendation and Local Broadcast Television with the caveat that the Local Broadcast TV compress the seventeen weeks to somewhere closer to thirteen.
What tipped the scales might have been the Billfish tournament marketing. Obviously, the Billfish Tournament is a major draw to our area and can be capitalized on with the target markets. What Gray Television plans to do is have a thirty minute show which showcases the event and the destination, giving Panama City Beach loads of face time including promotional opportunities with sports and weather. Overall, JB Inc.’s and LBTV’s recommendations should make for a good buy.
One interesting tid-bit in the meeting was a quick discussion about marketing to future potential markets like Chicago and NY. With the new airport these areas, which previously had been virtually avoided in terms of marketing, could become gold. If you have analytics you know that NY and CHI rank high on traffic on Panama City Beach sites already. It might not be a bad idea to start early with a great/new/first impression, lathering up new potential vacationers and snowbirds for a trip to PCB.